Introduction this memo is a failure analysis report on the tacoma narrows bridge. You can actually see the cables snap in barney elliotts video. The first modern major suspension bridges was thomas telfords menai strait suspension bridge completed in 1825. Resonance, tacoma narrows bridge failure, and undergraduate physics textbooks pg 1. The tacoma narrows bridge collapses due to high winds on november 7, 1940. Within four months of that date it was a twisted pile of wreckage at the bottom of the gorge. The tacoma narrows bridge is famous for collapsing in a spectacular fashion during a windstorm. On november 7, 1940, the tacoma narrows bridge tnb collapsed and a movie 1. The 40plusmileperhour winds the day the bridge came down were so extreme and unrelenting, the vibrational energy became more than the cables were able to absorb. Only four months later, the great spans short life ended in disaster. Feldman, what to say about the tacoma narrows bridge to your introductory physics class, phys. Essay about failure analysis report on the tacoma narrows bridge. Notably, in many undergraduate physics texts the disaster is presented as an example of elementary forced resonance of a mechanical oscillator, with the wind providing an external periodic frequency that matched the natural structural frequency.
The tacoma narrows bridge is a pair of twin suspension bridges that span the tacoma narrows strait of puget sound in pierce county, washington. The bridges connect the city of tacoma with the kitsap peninsula and carry state route 16 known as primary state highway 14 until 1964 over the strait. Comparison of torsional flexibility of tacoma narrows bridge with others table 6. Resonance, tacoma narrows bridge failure, and undergraduate physics textbooks k. The collapse of the tacoma narrows bridge on the morning of november 7, 1940, is the most iconic example of a spectacular bridge failure in modern times. It was designed by leon moisseiff and at its time it was the third largest suspension. Situated on the tacoma narrows in puget sound, near the city of tacoma, washington, the bridge had only been open for traffic a few months. Despite the engineers promise that the bridge would withstand hurricane force winds, the bridge quickly earned the nickname galloping gertie for its habit of swaying in even modern breezes. During that brief period, it became an attraction as it oscillated, at a relatively low amplitude a few feet in a number of di. Old and new explanations of the tacoma narrows bridge collapse. Failure knowledge database 100 selected cases 1 collapse of tacoma narrows bridge november 7, 1940 in tacoma, washington, usa masayuki nakao institute of engineering innovation, school of engineering, the university of tokyo the tacoma narrows bridge in the state of washington was completed and opened to traffic on july 1, 1940. Tacoma narrows bridge spanning puget sound death of dog. Agency fwa investigated the collapse of the tacoma narrows bridge. Ethical issues from the tacoma narrows bridge collapse live webinar 2012 instructor.
Hook many physicists and physics students have seen videos of the famous bridge disaster that occurred 75 years ago this month. Bridge building activity or competition build a bridge from string, sticky tape and drinking straws a great activity at home, or a class competition. On the morning of november 7, 1940, the tacoma narrows bridge twisted violently in 42mileperhour winds and collapsed into the cold waters of the puget sound. This was indeed a catastrophic failure but it taught us how to build safer. The tacoma narrows bridge failure is an example of selfexcited vibration of such importance that it warrants its own section in this document. It is simply that the profession had neglected to combine, and apply in.
Ethical issues from the tacoma narrows bridge collapse. The tacoma narrows bridge failure revision a by tom irvine. As the third largest suspension bridge in the world, behind only the george washington and golden gate bridges. Ethical issues from the tacoma narrows bridge collapse course no. On november 7, j ust four months after the opening, it collapsed due to windinduced oscillations. The tacoma narrows bridge at puget sound in the state of washington was completed and opened to traffic on july 1, 19 40. Watch the amazing gallopin gertie november 7, 1940 film clip. The 1940 tacoma narrows bridge, the first tacoma narrows bridge, was a suspension bridge in the u. The tacoma narrows bridge failure revision a by tom irvine email. Since the opening day on july 1, 1940, the tacoma narrows bridge has been a topic of interest for. Its main span collapsed into the tacoma narrows four months later on november 7, 1940, due to a physical phenomenon known as aeroelastic flutter caused by a 42 mph wind.
The first tacoma narrows bridge opened to traffic on july 1, 1940. Ppt tacoma narrows bridge powerpoint presentation free to. Tacoma bridge failure a physical model daniel green and william g. Includes pdf file of haer historic architecture and engineering record wa99 for tacoma narrows bridge.
Tacoma narrows bridge collapse gallopin gertie youtube. The tacoma narrows bridge opened to traffic on july 1, 1940. The tacoma narrows bridge was particularly narrow relative to its length, making the roadbed more flexible than other suspension bridges. The dramatic tacoma narrows bridge disaster of 1940 is still very much in the public eye today. Tacoma narrows bridge is the property of its rightful owner. Failure ensued, and the tacoma narrows bridge was rebuilt with stiffening trusses included. A new mathematical explanation of the tacoma narrows. Most of these bridges, like tacoma bridge collapse casestacoma narrows matdl. Department of transportation federal highway administration fhwa is charged with the broad responsibility of ensuring that americas roads and highways continue to be the safest and most technologically uptodate. Tacoma narrows bridge an overview sciencedirect topics. The footage became the basis for a textbook example of resonance, which is a standard topic in high school physics. Each bridge failure has its unique features which makes it difficult to generalize the causes of failures. When the tacoma narrows bridge over puget sound in the state of washington famously collapsed on november 7, 1940, it was captured on film for posterity. For over six decades, engineers have studied the collapse of the 1940 tacoma narrows bridge.
Replacement bridge a new tacoma narrows bridge was built in 1950, as shown in figure 5. The tacoma narrows bridge also known as galloping gertie is a wellknown and welldocumented suspension bridge failure that occurred on november 7, 1940 at approximately 11am, four months after the bridge was first opened to the public. Nevertheless, the bridge s collapse remains the most wellknow structural failure due to vibration. Tacoma narrows bridge failure, and undergraduate physics textbooks, am. Apr 14, 2017 in the case of the tacoma narrows bridge, the cables transferred the energy to the towers and support structures. The third longest suspension span in the world opened on july 1st. Unruh department of physics and astronomy university of british columbia vancouver, bc, canada, v6t 1z1 email. The tacoma narrows bridge was three times more flexible than the. Dimensions of suspension bridges with spans of 1200 feet or over table 7. The tacoma narrows bridge was the first suspension bridge to use solid ibeams to support the roadbed. The gradual elimination of stiffening trusses and ties culminated in their absence from the tacoma narrows bridge. The bridges collapse has been described as spectacular and in. Unruhb department of physics and astronomy, university of british columbia, vancouver, bc v6t 1z1, canada received 23 august 2004.
Pdf failures of bridges have occurred ever since bridge building started. Between 1939 and 1940, the tacoma narrows bridge over the puget sound between tacoma and gig harbor, washington. Tacoma narrows bridge bridge, washington, united states. Many mischaracterizations of the observed phenomena have limited the understanding of the collapse even though there has always been an abundance of evidence in favor of a negative damping model. A new mathematical explanation of what triggered the catastrophic. The tacoma narrows wasnt the only new suspension bridge of the period that suffered from excessive motion. It was located in washington state, near puget sound. The experts disagree, at least on some aspects of the explanation.
The tacoma narrows bridge was well known for its vertical oscillations. On november 7, 1940, just four months after it opened, as the bridge was engaging in its usual vertical activity, the nature of. It just so happens that with this bridge, the natural frequency was close to the surrounding winds which caused the bridge to oscillate so violently that it caused its own destruction. The cause of the collapse of the tacoma narrows bridge has been a topic of much debate and confusion over the years. It collapsed on november 7, 1940 just months after its opening on july 1, 1940. The collapse of the tacoma narrows bridge tnb, which occurred on november. The collapse of the tacoma narrows bridge the tacoma narrows bridge is perhaps the most notorious failure in the world of engineering. Course the tacoma narrows bridge was completed and opened to traffic on july 1, 1940. At first, the bridges deck began to experience vertical moment as a result of severe winds. About 45 minutes before failure, a different kind of oscillation started.
This bridge was the third largest suspension bridge in the world for its time. Comparison of torsional deformation of tacoma narrows bridge with others table 5. Resonance, tacoma narrows bridge failure, and undergraduate. The tacoma narrows bridge failure revision a by tom. Earlier suspension bridge designs typically had open lattice beam trusses supporting the roadbed. Tacoma narrows bridge learning from building failures. It was a suspension bridge that spanned puget sounds tacoma narrows straight. These failures provide some insight into negligence and also the importance of innovative structural design. This weakness was due to the shallowness of the stiffening girders and the narrowness of the roadway, relative to its span length. The tacoma narrows bridge was the thirdlongest suspension bridge in the united states at the. The tacoma narrows bridge failure university of michigan.
Bridge overload and lateral impact forces from trucks, bargesships, and trains resulted in around 20% of the total bridge failures. Tacoma narrows bridge steel procurement background on the tacoma narrows bridge project the tacoma narrows bridge project will result in two parallel suspension bridges between tacoma and gig harbor. The collapse of the tacoma narrows bridge, 7 november 1940. If so, share your ppt presentation slides online with. If you are putting together a list of failed projects from the history books it would be hard to ignore the tacoma narrows bridge. The principal causes of bridge failures were categorized as deficiencies in design, detailing, construction. The original tacoma narrows bridge was built between november 1938 and july 1, 1940. The tacoma narrows bridge probably the most widely reported and thus most famous bridge failure of all time, the 1940 failure of the tacoma narrows suspension bridge figure 1, represents a classic case of the consequences of pushing a design too far. Between 1818 and 1889, the wind destroyed or seriously damaged ten suspension bridges petroski, 1994. On july 1st, 1940, the tacoma narrows bridge opened to the public in washington. With earlier designs wind would pass through the truss and have minimal effect on the structure. The tacoma narrows bridge collapse on film and video article pdf available in the physics teacher 538. The tacoma narrows bridge opened on july 1, 1940 and collapsed on november 7, 1940 under winds of approximately 40 mph.
The day of its failure, the tacoma narrows bridge did experience resonance from the vortex shedding. Tacoma narrows bridge collapse franklin miller, jr. Jul 08, 20 the tacoma narrows bridge is a pair of twin suspension bridges that span the tacoma narrows strait of puget sound in pierce county, washington. At the time of its opening in summer 1940 it was the worlds third longest suspension bridge. It opened to traffic on july 1, 1940, and dramatically collapsed into puget sound on november 7 the same year. Based on the system of equations the bridge was modeled after the natural frequency is the eigenvalue of the smallest magnitude of oscillation. You can see this in the vertical undulations for which the bridge was famous. Essay about failure analysis report on the tacoma narrows.
Michael sullivan talks about the 1940 tacoma narrows bridge collapse and its effects on the study of bridge design and civil engineering cspans local content vehicles lcvs made a stop in. The board of engineers appointed by you to report on the failure of the tacoma narrows bridge have made a complete investigation of the design, the behaviour after completion and the failure of the structure. Tacoma, washington tacoma narrows bridge spanning puget sound death of dog. Suspension bridges tacoma narrows bridge the over confidence in design, and lack of proper awareness of earlier problems eventually resulted in the classic failure of the tacoma narrows bridge in the usa in 1940. The objective is to build a bridge across a gap between two tables, using just string, sellotape and some maybe 10 drinkingart straws. Tacoma narrows bridge after the failure failure theories candidates the fundamental weakness of the tacoma narrows bridge was its extreme flexibility, both vertically and in torsion. Improving the mathematical model of the tacoma narrows bridge. Following delays, several lawsuits and modified legislation, wsdot signed a designbuild agreement with tacoma narrows constructors a joint venture with bechtel infrastructure and kiewit construction to not only build a new eastbound tacoma narrows bridge, but also a new toll facility and plaza, 3. The bridge collapsed on november 7th, 1940 just over four months after it was opened to the public on july 1st, 1940green, 2006. Pdf the tacoma narrows bridge collapse on film and video. A new mathematical explanation of the tacoma narrows bridge. Dec 09, 2006 watch the amazing gallopin gertie november 7, 1940 film clip. A new mathematical explanation of the tacoma narrows bridge collapse gianni arioli. Its main span collapsed into the tacoma narrows four months later on november 7, 1940, at 11.
More importantly, it abruptly ended an entire generation of bridge engineering theory and practice, and the trend in designing increasingly flexible, light, and slender suspension spans. The bridge collapse had lasting effects on science and engineering. A summary of others published findings on the causes of the collapse of the tacoma narrows bridge it was not resonance, suitable for undergraduate students. A definitive description that meets unanimous agreement has not been reached. The doomed tacoma narrows bridge on opening day, july 1, 1940, image via university of washington libraries digital collections. Slender, elegant and graceful, the tacoma narrows bridge stretched like a steel ribbon across puget sound in 1940. The failure of the tacoma narrows bridge caltechauthors. On the day the bridge failed, the wind was blowing across the roadbed at 42 mph, the strongest wind the bridge had experienced. Coordination forced oscillation, it costs several dollars. The spectacular collapse of the tacoma narrows bridge has attracted the. Strength versus weight contradictions in bridge design. The failure of the tacoma narrows bridge effectively ended moisseiffs career. Plans to install the integral vehicular link date back as far as 1889, when the northern pacific railway first drafted concepts for a trestle bridge.
For additional images and documents relating to the history of the tacoma narrows bridge, see the tacoma narrows bridge collection on the uw libraries digital collections website. The tacoma bridge on november 7, 1940, at approximately 11. Carmody, administrator, federal works agency, washington, d. Pacific time as a result of aeroelastic flutter caused by a 42 mph 68 kmh wind. Four months after its opening, on the morning of november 7, 1940, in a wind of about 42. The failure is extremely well documented in this context in reference 1. The tacoma narrows bridge was built in washington during the 1930s and opened to traffic on july 1, 1940. May 24, 2017 the collapse of the tacoma narrows bridge on the morning of november 7, 1940, is the most iconic example of a spectacular bridge failure in modern times. Nov 05, 2019 the tacoma narrows bridge collapses due to high winds on november 7, 1940. The great engineering failure of the tacoma narrows bridge.
The catastrophic engineering failure would strengthen research into bridge aerodynamics and aerolastics, research that continues to influence the design of longspan bridges around the world. The golden gate bridge 1937, new yorks bronxwhitestone 1939, and maines deer isle bridge 1939 also demonstrated an alarming tendency to undulate in the wind and all had to be retrofitted with extra cables andor stiffening devices. The original tacoma narrows bridge was opened to traffic on july 1, 1940. The new bridge will open in 2007 and upgrades to the existing bridge will finish in 2008. The exact cause of the bridge s failure remains a mystery. The tacoma narrows bridge collapse highlighted the importance of failure case studies in engineering education. The collapse of the tacoma narrows bridge essay 2336 words. Tacoma narrows bridge, first suspension bridge across the narrows of puget sound, connecting the olympic peninsula with the mainland of washington state, u.
This month marks the 75th anniversary of the tacoma narrows bridge collapse. In this lesson, youll dive into the physics of this collapse by learning about resonance frequency. Specifically, a strong political push for a bridge, but one that was going to. Many mischaracterizations of the observed phenomena have limited the understanding of the collapse even though there has always been an abundance of evidence in favor of a.
1352 707 138 428 1215 541 596 580 809 127 1568 1018 200 1347 1199 75 1209 449 886 1481 209 1428 877 1180 235 1218 1201 284 755 156 342 905 1069 350 262